Book One: About War
Summarized description for Book One: About War
About War is the first book in the trilogy Making Sense of War and discusses war and its role in human history, including its impact on great empires, art, literature, and innovation. It emphasises that war is a political act and every action should be concerned with achieving peace and a better political balance.
About War examines the international context for war and examples of attempts to control and moderate it, as well as the relationship between politicians and the military.
It argues that contemporary procedures and processes for the governance of the nation-state at war within the Western model of liberal, democratic government disregards the anarchic nature of international relations. As such, the governance of wars is inadequate to cope with the planning and prosecution of future wars.
About War also discusses nuclear weapons and their risks, the importance of nuclear non-proliferation, and the need to minimize the risks of nuclear war.
Overall, About War explores how to think about war, how to put meaning, direction, and purpose into a coherent framework, and draws on examples from the UK’s experience and governance of wars.
Topics covered:
War in History: The Persistence of War
What is War?
Causes of War; Causes of Peace
The International Context
Politics and ‘Politics’
Strategy as the Link between Politics and the Use of Armed Force
Civil–Military Relations and Governance
Legitimate or Illegitimate War?
Technology and the Military–industrial Complex
Nuclear Considerations
The Future for War
Reconciling the Narrative
Summarized Chapter What is War? in About War
The concept of war is interpreted differently among generations and cultures. Older generations may associate war with the titanic struggle against fascism in World War II; subsequent generations have limited exposure to war and may view it as something that happens ‘somewhere else’. War is a political act, and defining it precisely is challenging since it involves enormous human cost, and uncertain political outcomes.
The United Nations Charter forbids war, and they have no specific definition of it but instead identifies ‘aggression’. The French definition views war as a state of armed conflict between several constituted political groups, such as states, making it an act of foreign policy or defence. The French define war as the last resort after diplomatic negotiations.
Defining war in various countries’ constitutions is difficult since there are no clear guidelines or definitions. The U.S. Constitution contains fewer words devoted to Congress’s role in declaring war than the issue of copyrights and patents. The U.S. Department of Defense has a publication entitled ‘DOD Dictionary of Military and Associated Terms’, which contains no definition of war. Similarly, the United Kingdom constitution, being largely uncodified, has no specific guidance on the subject.
Warfare, on the other hand, is the practice of conducting war on the battlefield or war-space. It is the realm of soldiers, sailors, and airmen, of munitions, logistics, and geography, and increasingly, cyber-warriors. The media’s general portrayal of war focuses on ruined cities or discussions on defence budgets rather than politics and social considerations. For example, the bombing of Libya in 2011 ignored the tribal divisions that were only kept under control by the dictator, Muammar Gaddafi, and removing him inevitably resulted in carnage.
No two wars are the same since and their outcomes unknown – some social scientists hold that only half of wars achieve the original objective. What the Americans call the ‘blood and treasure’ costs are considerable and unknown at the start of the conflict.. For instance, the Football War fought between El Salvador and Honduras in 1969 had about 3,000 casualties compared to Nazi Germany versus Soviet Russia, which had more than 14 million military deaths and 20 million civilian deaths.
In conclusion, war is a complex concept that is almost impossible to define precisely. War is a political act, and warfare is the practice of conducting war on the battlefield or war-space.
Media’s portrayal of war often focuses too much on the consequences rather than politics and social considerations, leading to a limited understanding of the overall concept.